Monday, August 5, 2019

WHY THE "ALLEGED ONSET DATE" IS SO IMPORTANT

When you file a Social Security disability claim, you will be asked the date you became disabled.  This is called the "Alleged Onset Date" (AOD). Potentially, the claim will pay a benefit back to this date.  So, choose the date with care.

There are two important things to consider when choosing your alleged onset date (AOD):

1.  You must not have been working on the alleged onset date and you must not have worked at any substantial gainful job after the AOD. A job is usually "substantial" if it was full time work.  

2.  You must have medical evidence of disability going back to the alleged onset date.  If not, Social Security will move the onset date forward, causing you to lose some past due benefits.

So, if Mr. Claimant comes to my office for help filing a disability claim, here are the questions I need to ask him about his AOD:

  • When did your medical impairment first become so severe that you could not work?
  • Have you worked any at all since that date?  If yes, was any of that work performed at "substantial gainful activity? level?  (If yes, the onset date must be changed to a later date).
There is a Social Security rule that basically says a person cannot be disabled while working a full-time job.  Even if you feel you were disabled while you continued to work, Social Security will not pay a benefit for any month in which you worked at the level of "substantial gainful activity.)*  So, generally, you can't claim a benefit while you were still working, regardless of your medical condition.

While an alleged onset date may be amended or changed after the claim has been filed, it is best to begin with a date that can be defended.  I recommend that you speak with an attorney or advocate who handles disability claims before you decide on an onset date. If there are legal problems with the onset date, the attorney/advocate can save you a lot of headaches.

Put the most simple way, the alleged onset date (AOD) is:  the date when the claimant became medically unable to work and, therefore, stopped working.
____________
Charles W. Forsythe
The Forsythe Firm
7027 Old Madison Pike, Suite 108
Huntsville, AL 35806
CALL US:  (256) 799-0297

SOCIAL SECURITY JUSTICE 

Serving Alabama and Tennessee

                                                          REPRESENTING WITH RESPECT AND DIGNITY


Sunday, August 4, 2019

SSI and WHO IT IS FOR

You may hear the Social Security disability program called "SSI."  However, SSI is not the same as Social Security disability (SSDI).

SSI stands for "Supplemental Security Income," a welfare-like program for claimants who have little financial resources.

SSDI - is "Social Security Disability Insurance," earned by working and paying into the trust fund over a period of years.

The major differences include:

1.  Work Credits.  You are not required to have worked and paid any FICA tax to be covered for SSI but this isn't true for SSDI.  SSDI requires the claimant to have worked a certain amount and paid into the trust fund to be "insured."

2.  Means Testing.  SSDI is not means tested.  A claimant doe not need to have few financial resources or restricted income to qualify for SSDI.  However, SSI is for persons with very limited household income and few financial resources.

3.  Very Different Benefit Amounts.  The maximum federal benefit for SSI is currently $750 per month.  Many claimants get less, but $750 is the most you can get.  However, SSDI may pay a maximum of $2,788 per month.  The actual amount is based on your average wages.

4.  Comes with Different Health Insurance.  SSDI benefits come with Medicare insurance but SSI benefits come with Medicaid.

TWO CASE STUDIES

Alice worked for 15 years and paid FICA tax to Social Security with each paycheck through payroll deduction, which is mandatory.  She has earned enough quarters of coverage at work to be covered by SSDI under Title II of the Social Security Act.  Alice became disabled and applied for SSDI benefits.  She has substantial savings and also owns investment property worth more than $100,000.  She was awarded SSDI benefits and receives a monthly payment of $2,145 per month.

Zachary once worked but stopped working in 2011. He lives alone.  Zachary inherited some money and property when his parents died.  The property is worth $50,000, not including the house he lives in.  He has about $3,000 in a savings account at the bank. In 2019, he became disabled and files for SSDI.  He is told that he doesn't have sufficient work credits to be covered by SSDI.  Zachary protests that he worked for many years and paid FICA tax up until 2011.  However, that was not recent enough and his SSDI coverage had expired on 12/31/16.  Zachary then files an SSI claim because it requires no work credits.  However, his SSI claim is denied because Zachary has too many financial resources.  He is disqualified because of the property he owns and the $3,500 in savings.  He is told that SSI is like Welfare; it is only intended for persons with very restricted income and resources.  In fact, an individual is qualified for SSI only if he/she has less than $2,000 in countable resources.

So, Alice had a great deal of financial resources and even some income from her investment property but was still able to receive $2,145 per month in SSDI benefits from Social Security.  The rationale is that Alice paid into the system recently enough to have SSDI insurance coverage and there are no income/resource restrictions on SSDI.  However, Zachary has not worked recently enough to have SSDI insurance coverage (expired 12/31/15).  And he has too many resources to qualify for SSI.

These two case studies illustrate the fundamental differences between SSDI (Title 2) and SSI (Title 16). 

Both SSI and SSDI are administered by the Social Security Administration and both get called "Social Security disability."  But this is not true, as you have seen.  They are very, very different programs.

So, which program should you apply for if you become disabled?  The answer is SSDI (Title 2) if you can qualify.  It will probably pay a higher benefit and has no requirement that you be poor or have limited resources.  However, if you don't have the required work credits, you should check on SSI.  Sometimes, SSI is available when SSDI is not.
_________________
The Forsythe Firm
7027 Old Madison Pike, Suite 108
Huntsville, AL 35802
PHONE (256) 799-0297

Located directly across from Bridge Street Town Centre.

COSTLY MISTAKES CLAIMANTS MAKE WITH SOCIAL SECURITY CLAIMS

Social Security disability is a complex, complicated and confusing maze of forms, rules and regulations.  Getting a disability benefit is not easy.  Here are some common costly mistakes that claimants make:

1.  Waiting too long to file a claim.  After you stop working your SSDI eligibility will eventually expire.  If you wait too long to file, you may run past your Date Last Insured and have problems.

2.  Claiming the wrong alleged onset date.  Choosing the date of application as the alleged onset date can cost you thousands of dollars in past due benefits.  Often, the date of application is not the correct date of onset.  Take your claim back as far as possible to get maximum benefits.

3.  Failing to acquire adequate medical documentation.  Disability will only be approved for claimants who have solid medical proof of disability.  This requires doctor's records and hopefully imaging studies and laboratory tests to show the exact nature and severity of your medical conditions.

4.  Failure to file a timely appeal if the claim is denied.  Denials are common.  In 2019, only about 1 in 5 claims will be approved at the application stage.  4 out of 5 claims will require an appeal and hearing before they can be paid.  After you receive a denial letter, you have only 60 days by law to file an appeal. If you wait longer, you cannot appeal but you might be able to file a new claim and start over.  This will cost you money, as some benefits will be lost.

5.  Trying to handle things yourself (pro se) without legal counsel. Self-representation can be dangerous, especially at the appeal/hearing level.  The typical claimant doesn't know Social Security rules and regulations (thousands of pages of them) and, therefore, will have difficulty proving disability according to the regulations.  This requires knowledge and skill--the work of a trained and experienced representative who knows the law and the process.  We have proven over and over that "good representation isn't expensive; it's priceless."  And our clients agree.  Just read our reviews.

6.  Completing forms or questionnaires in a sloppy, inaccurate or incomplete manner.  Each form has a purpose and while they may be tedious and time-consuming, it's important to fill out the forms completely and in accurate detail.
____________
The Forsythe Firm
Social Security Disability Specialists
7027 Old Madison Pike, Suite 108
Huntsville, AL 35806
CALL US:  (256) 799-0297

Serving all of North Alabama and Middle Tennessee



Saturday, August 3, 2019

CAN YOU RECEIVE PAST DUE DISABILITY CHECKS?

If Social Security issues a Fully Favorable or Partially Favorable decision on your disability case, it means that you have been found to be disabled and eligible for benefits.

The next question is when you became disabled according to Social Security's rules.  The date your disability began is called the onset date.  There are actually two onset dates:

1.  The alleged onset date (AOD) is the date of disability claimed in the application.  It is "alleged" because it has not yet been proven or established.

2. The established onset date (EOD) is the date that Social Security decision makers accept as the date you became disabled.  This forms the date to which your benefits will be paid, minus any required waiting period (5 months for SSDI claims).

If you received a Fully Favorable decision, it means that Social Security has accepted your alleged onset date (AOD) as the date you first became disabled.  In this case, the alleged onset date becomes the established onset date (EOD).

If you receive a Partially Favorable decision, it means that you are found disabled but at a later date than your alleged onset date (AOD).  For example, you may have claimed to have become disabled on 2/1/17 but Social Security found that you did not become disabled under their rules until 4/1/18.  This change of the onset date results in two important consequences:

1)  It reduces your back pay because it shaves the period between 2/1/17 and 4/1/18 off your benefit period.

2)  It increases how long you must wait to be eligible for Medicare coverage under a Title 2 claim.  Medicare coverage becomes available 29 months after the established onset date.  So the earlier your established onset date the earlier you will be able to get Medicare coverage.

Why would Social Security not accept your earlier alleged onset date (AOD)?  There are two common reasons:

One, you may have worked at substantial gainful employment after your AOD.  For example, your alleged onset date is 2/1/17 but you continued to work through 3/31/18.  Even if you were medically disabled on 2/1/17, you could not be legally disabled under Social Security's rules  because you were working.  So the decision maker moves the onset date forward to the day after your last day of work.

Another reason is that the objective medical evidence may not prove disability back to the alleged onset date.  Perhaps you developed a serious medical condition around 2/1/17 but you received little or no medical treatment for the condition until March of 2018.  Therefore, you may have been disabled earlier but you can't prove it because there are no medical records dating back to 2/1/17.

I think the obvious point here is this:  If you have a serious medical condition that may lead you to file a disability claim, go to the doctor as soon as possible for examination and treatment.  Establish a medical record of your condition and symptoms as soon as possible. 

There is one other factor that affects how much back pay will accumulate in your disability claim:  how long will it take Social Security to decide whether you are disabled?

Initial applications often take 4 or 5 months to reach a decision.  Up to 75 percent of those decisions are denials.  So, if you must file an appeal and have a hearing, it will take an additional 12 to 18 months to get the hearing.  Past due benefits potentially accumulate while you wait for a favorable decision. One you get a favorable decision, the past due benefits become payable--all the way back to your AOD, minus any waiting period (typically 5 months).

Of course, you want to get all the back pay to which you are entitled.  Most likely, you have bills that piled up while you were waiting to be approved.  Back pay can help settle those bills and give you a fresh start.

An attorney or advocate familiar with Social Security law will work to obtain all the back pay available in your case.  Usually, the attorney (called a "representative" by Social Security) will pay for himself ten times over by getting you an earlier onset date and more back pay.  If he/she does not get back pay for you, you actually pay nothing in attorney's fees.

____________
Charles W. Forsythe
Social Security Disability Representation
7027 Old Madison Pike, Suite 108
Huntsville, AL 35806
CALL US:  (256) 799-0297

SOCIAL SECURITY JUSTICE (WEBSITE)




 

Friday, August 2, 2019

PAST RELEVANT WORK AND WHY IT IS IMPORTANT

At Step 4 of the sequential process, Social Security must determine whether the claimant is able to perform any of his/her past relevant work (PRW).

PRW is defined as any job the claimant has performed within the previous 15 years, and work which was
(A) performed at the level of substantial gainful activity, and
(B) performed long enough to learn how to do the work.

How does Social Security gather information about Past Relevant Work?  They use two methods:

First, during the application process, each claimant fills out a Work History Report in which they list each job and the duties associated with each one.  The claimant will describe how much each job required him/her to stand, walk, sit, lift, bend, stoop, reach, etc.
 

Also, during a hearing at the appeal level, the judge will take testimony from the claimant about each past relevant job.  

Finally, at the appeal hearing, the judge will obtain testimony from a vocational witness who will describe each job in terms of (a) the exertion level and (b) the skill level and amount of training required for each job. 

If the claimant has reached age 55, eligibility for disability benefits may hinge completely on whether he/she is able to perform any past relevant work.  For individuals below age 50, past relevant work may not be as critical to the outcome of the claim.

I recommend that each claimant for disability benefits fill out the Work History Report with accuracy and attention to detail.  
 ______________
The Forsythe Firm
7027 Old Madison Pike - Suite 108
Huntsville, AL 35806
PHONE (256) 799-0297

"SOCIAL SECURITY JUSTICE" 






Thursday, August 1, 2019

WHY ARE DISABILITY CLAIMS DISMISSED?

Social Security may dismiss a Social Security disability appeal under certain circumstances.

One of the common reasons for dismissal is filing the appeal too late; that is, missing the 60 day deadline to file an appeal.  The 60 days start ticking with the date on the denial letter.  You can add 5 extra days for mailing time.  So, if your appeal is not filed within 65 days from the date of denial, it will be dismissed for "untimely filing."

A claim may be dismissed because the claimant doesn't have enough "work credits" to be insured under the Social Security Act.  Most workers need to have worked 5 years out of the most recent 10-year period to have coverage.  Exceptions apply for very young persons.

A claim can also be dismissed at the request of the claimant.  If the claimant has returned to work, for example, he or she may ask the court to dismiss the claim. 

If your claim gets dismissed, may you appeal?  Yes.  You may file an appeal with the appellate division, commonly called the Appeals Council--which is a group of judges headquartered in Falls Church, Virginia.  

If your claim was dismissed due to late filing (missing the deadline), you must show that you had "good cause" for the late filing.  If you don't have enough work credits to be covered under the Social Security Act, the appeal will only be successful if you can prove that Social Security is wrong about the credits you have and you actually have more credits than are showing in the record.

So, appeals for these kind of issues are very difficult to win.

If you have a question or problem regarding Social Security disability, you should consult an experienced attorney or advocate who deals with these matters on a regular basis.
__________________
The Forsythe Firm
7027 Old Madison Pike, Suite 108
"Across from Bridge Street"
Huntsville, AL 35806

Serving Madison, Morgan, Limestone, Lawrence, Marshall, Jackson & Cullman counties.  Also serving middle Tennessee.

DO DISABLED PERSONS ALWAYS GET BENEFITS?

Just because you deserve Social Security disability benefits does not mean that you will be approved. At least one-half of the individuals who are legitimately disabled will be denied when they file an application for benefits.

There are several reasons for this high denial rate.  One is that the very definition of disability is so strict and narrow in the regulations.  Generally, you must be totally unable to do any type of full-time work that exists in the American economy.  It's an all-or-none determination; you are totally disabled or not disabled at all -- nothing between.

Second, the burden of proving disability rests with the claimant.  The government doesn't have to prove that you are not disabled; you must prove that you are.  This requires clear and convincing medical evidence.

Third, the system is far from perfect.  A person who has never met you will look at your medical records and decide whether you are disabled according to the federal regulations.  You don't get to appear and explain your case.  
Finally, you are not given the benefit of the doubt.  If the case is uncertain, a denial is the default and common response.  That's why about 75 percent of all disability applications will be denied.

Fortunately, there is a way to fix this problem.  It's called an appeal.  Like all other aspects of the American judicial system, there are checks and balances.  If you are denied, the solution is to file an appeal.  You only have 60 days from the date of denial to do this.  This deadline is very strict.  In most cases, if you fail to appeal within 60 days, your case will be dismissed with no further action available on the claim.

So, what are your odds at the appeal?  In 2019, approximately 45 percent of all denied claims will be approved at the appeal process.  So, there is almost a one-in-two chance of being approved at appeal--much better than the odds at the application level.  Having an attorney or qualified advocate assist you with the appeal (and appear with you at the hearing) can increase your chance of approval.

The appeal hearing is a legal process during which you have a chance to appear for the first time, with your attorney, and prove your disability.  You must prove this according to the 20 Code of Federal Regulations, the rulings of the Social Security Administration, recent court decisions, and other criteria. It isn't a matter of just walking into the hearing and telling a good story.  The question is:  Where does the law say that you meet the definition of "disability"?

The long-and-short of a Social Security disability claim is:  YOU CAN PROBABLY WIN IT ON APPEAL.

A hearing gives you a completely new review of your case, without consideration to any decision Social Security has made in the past.  It's a new beginning.  So, by all means, when Social Security denies, appeal the decision.  The appeal is where a majority of claims get approved.
______________
The Forsythe Firm
7027 Old Madison Pike - Suite 108
"Across from Bridge Street"
Huntsville, AL 35806
PHONE US:  (256) 799-0297

WEBSITE "SOCIAL SECURITY JUSTICE"


 

SIGNS YOU MAY HAVE WON YOUR DISABILITY HEARING

  SIGNS YOU MAY HAVE WON YOUR DISABILITY HEARING If your Social Security disability claim was denied, you will usually appear before an Adm...